Closer look: Outside spending in race that unseated Massie
The race for Kentucky’s 4th congressional seat goes down as the most expensive primary in U.S. House history, but most of the money flowing in to unseat Thomas Massie came from out of state.
The race for Kentucky’s 4th congressional seat goes down as the most expensive primary in U.S. House history, but most of the money flowing in to unseat Thomas Massie came from out of state.
The race for Kentucky’s 4th congressional seat goes down as the most expensive primary in U.S. House history, but most of the money flowing in to unseat Thomas Massie came from out of state.
The race for Kentucky’s 4th congressional seat goes down as the most expensive primary in U.S. House history, but most of the money flowing in to unseat Thomas Massie came from out of state.
Looking at donations since the start of the year, the number of contributions to Ed Gallrein and Thomas Massie’s campaigns by Kentuckians didn't crack 6%, according to the Federal Election Commission.
Contributions made to the campaigns from New York, California, and Washington, D.C. made up 20% of donations to Gallrein's campaign and around 15% of Massie’s campaign.
According to AdImpact, $32.6 million was spent on advertising in the race that cost Thomas Massie his seat on Capitol Hill. Pro-Ed Gallrein spending topped $18 million. Pro-Massie spending neared $14 million.
Federal Election Commission records show pro-Israel groups played a major part in the flood of advertising.
The United Democracy Project, a group supported by the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, spent more than $4 million on advertising opposing Massie and supporting Gallrein.
MAGA Kentucky, a political PAC supported by billionaire Paul Singer, was among the largest contributors to take Massie down, with more than $11.2 million spent.
Kentucky 4th PAC spent $6.6 million in advertising opposing Gallrein. Federal records do not show who has contributed to the political action committee.
Gov. Andy Beshear reacted in a post on social media.
"Thomas Massie and I don't agree on much, but billionaires and special interest groups spent $35 million in Kentucky to unseat one conservative congressman - all because he stood up to Trump. It's everything that's wrong with our politics today," Beshear posted.
Stephen Voss, associate professor of political science at the University of Kentucky, said foreign policy played a significant role in the money against Massie, but that is likely not what cost him his seat.
“You don't normally see this much money spent in a congressional race,” Voss said. “We shouldn't take too far the idea that it's the pro-Israel lobby that took out Massie because the pro-Israel people have had a reason to target Massie for years.”
Voss said it was Massie’s already waning support from Trump voters and President Donald Trump himself that likely cost him his job. Voss does not downplay the ways that money helped Gallrein, a previously unknown figure.
“Gallrein had the resources to mount a serious challenge to Massie. So, we really had a rare instance of money mattering in politics,” Voss said. "Why? Because it went to the people who normally wouldn't have had a chance."
Voss also said he expects more money to continue to pour into Kentucky Republican primary elections in the future, because the primaries arguably matter more since the state has become reliably Republican.